39% of the renovations we have built had at least one change order. The average change order was $4,343. About 85% of them were things the homeowner asked to add. The rest were what the building hid behind the wall. None were a line we missed.
Most contractors will not tell you that number. Some do not know it. We pulled every project out of our project-management system this week, 36 jobs going back to 2023, and counted.
Here is what we found, and what it should mean for how you budget.
The numbers
- 36 projects in our system since 2023
- 12 had at least one change order (33% of everything, 39% of the jobs that actually got built)
- 19 change orders total
- Average change order: $4,343
- Largest: $18,411. Smallest: $572.
- Projects that had a change order usually had one or two, not five
- 85% were owner-requested additions, 15% were hidden conditions found after demo, and 0% were “we missed a line item.”
For context, published industry figures for residential remodeling put change orders somewhere between 30% and 50% of projects. We sit in the lower half of that range. We would like it lower, but we are not going to pretend it is zero.
What a change order actually is
A change order is a written, priced, signed addition or subtraction to the contract scope. It is not a surprise bill. If a contractor hands you a surprise bill at the end, that is a different problem.
Change orders come in three kinds, and which kind a contractor’s are tells you a lot:
1. You added something. You saw the bathroom gutted and decided to do the heated floor after all. The closet became a custom closet. The electrical got a few more circuits. This is your house and your call; you should just see the number before anyone cuts wood. About 85% of ours are this kind. Our largest, $18,411, was a homeowner expanding scope mid-project once they saw the work.
2. The building told us something it could not tell us before. A gas line where the drawings said nothing, joists notched by someone in 1974. On pre-war buildings this is real. It is the other 15% of ours. We open test areas during the walkthrough and price the known conditions into the base scope, which is why the share is small, but nobody can see through plaster.
3. The contractor missed it. A line item that should have been in the estimate and was not. Zero of ours fall here. That is the number we watch hardest, because it is the one that is on us.
Why the rate is not zero, and should not be
A contractor who advertises “no change orders” is doing one of two things: padding the base price so every surprise is already paid for by you, or eating costs until the job stops being worth finishing. Neither is good for you.
What you want is a contractor whose change orders are small, written, explained, and yours. Ours average about $4,300 on jobs that run $50,000 to $600,000, and most started with the client asking for more. That is a homeowner upgrading a project they are happy with, not a contractor fixing an estimate.
What this means for your budget
Three rules we give every client at the walkthrough:
- Carry a 10% to 15% contingency on anything pre-war. Not in the contract, in your own account. If you do not use it, you kept it.
- Make selections before demo. Half of “I changed my mind” change orders are really “I had not decided yet.” Tile, fixtures, appliances, hardware: pick them before the first wall comes down and your change-order odds drop a lot.
- Ask for the number before the work. Every change order we issue is a document with a price and a signature line. If a contractor says “we’ll figure it out at the end,” stop the work.
Why we are publishing this
Transparent pricing is on our website. It is easy to write. Publishing the number that shows where estimates fell short is harder, and it is the kind of thing we think a homeowner should be able to ask any contractor and get an answer to.
If you are planning a renovation in Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens or Northern New Jersey and want to see how we scope a job before the contract, book a walkthrough at calendly.com/designsbydandj or call 347-688-6897.
Designs by D and J LLC is a husband-and-wife design-build firm in Brooklyn. NY License #623750. NJ License #13VH12888200. MWBE certified.
Frequently asked questions
How common are change orders in a renovation?
Industry figures put them at 30% to 50% of residential projects. Across our own 36 projects since 2023, 39% of built jobs had at least one.
What is a typical change order amount?
Ours average $4,343, ranging from $572 to $18,411, on projects between $50,000 and $600,000.
Can I avoid change orders entirely?
You can avoid the ones caused by the contractor. On our recorded projects, 85% of change orders were homeowner additions, 15% were hidden conditions, and none were estimating misses. The fastest way to reduce your own is to finalize all selections before demolition.
Should a change order always be in writing?
Yes. A change order is a priced, signed scope change. Verbal changes are how disputes start.



